Tuesday, 5 February 2013

Communicating VALUES: looking at ads (1)

McCAIN

The current McCain ad, on etv around 7p, news time (that is all that is watched in this enterprise/household), is primitive, iniquitous and completely out of touch with current South African and world issues. That COULD have come at the end of this commentary, but an explanation follows. For those who don't know the commercial: it depicts a middle-class black family where the mother tells the father: look here, they say here fresh fruit and veggies are the best for your family. This is followed by images of the father toiling and sweating with a spade etc, and then the virtues of frozen veggies are extolled and the impression created that they are at least as good as fresh ones. Think again, think McCain. One could add selected punctuation marks: Think again! THINK, McCain!

While one appreciates the need for low-budget commercials that people can identify with, McCain and their ad agency (which planet do these guys live on???) really insult their target audience with this effort. The ad communicates and encourages the following values:

1. Working with the soil is difficult and back-breaking
2. Producing fresh food yourself is difficult
3. Working with the soil and producing food is undesirable for people moving upwards
4. Consumerism is the way to go
5. Plastic packaging is desirable and to be striven for if you are not a poor fool living on the platteland somewhere
6. Freezing stuff, so contributing to electricity costs, is desirable and to be striven towards
7. All of the above, contributing to an excessive carbon footprint, is absolutely wonderful

In a country where agricultural issues, food production, food security and electricity consumption are pertinent, this ad sends all the wrong messages to people who may not have the analytical skills to know what they are being dished up. Pun intended. The message is irresponsible and the intention cynical. South African consumers deserve better.

One wonders how this commercial would fare in a developed and aware environment like the EU. Ad agencies would probably not even CONTEMPLATE producing something like that, as the high environmental awareness in the EU would not accept such shoddy thinking. MCain, and its ad agency locally should strive to rectify the stuff-up. Seeing that the product, at this stage, fulfills a certain need, they should be more respectful of and responsible towards their audience by perhaps depicting food production as the most noble activity there is, with McCain adding value, or whatever they think they're doing. Bringing in message of dealing with their plastic packaging responsibly, using freezing space efficiently, or any such aware behaviour will not hurt their product. It will also not hurt the budget, and will at least create the impression that they and their agency are not cynical rip-offs, unaware of pressing global issues.

No comments:

Post a Comment